My own feet are wide right through — forefoot, heel, the lot — so for years I assumed “wide fit” was a simple, one-size-fits-all fix. It took hearing from readers with a very different problem to realise it isn’t. If you’ve got a genuinely wide forefoot but a narrower, well-defined heel, a “wide fit” shoe can still let you down — just in a different way. Instead of pinching your toes, it lets your heel slide around inside a shoe that was scaled up evenly rather than shaped for your actual foot.
Affiliate disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you buy something through one of these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Why This Happens
Not everyone with wide feet has wide heels. Some people need plenty of room across their toes and forefoot but a much closer fit around the back of the shoe.
The trouble is that a shoe labelled ‘wide fit’ doesn’t tell you exactly where that extra room has been added. Some styles are generous across the forefoot while keeping a fairly snug heel. Others feel roomy all the way through.
If the heel area is too loose, your foot may lift or slide as you walk. That can cause rubbing, blisters and the annoying feeling that your shoes are about to come off.
My own feet are wide right through, so this isn’t a problem I’ve personally struggled with. But I can certainly understand why having plenty of toe room is no consolation if your heels won’t stay put!
What Actually Helps
- A well-fitting heel counter — this is the part of the shoe that surrounds the back of your heel. Look for a shoe that holds your heel comfortably without pinching or rubbing. A firm heel counter can help, but it’s the overall fit that matters, not simply how stiff the back of the shoe feels.
- Adjustable lacing — if your shoes have an extra pair of eyelets near the top, try a heel-lock technique, sometimes called a runner’s loop. It can help hold your heel more securely without tightening the shoe across your toes. It’s worth trying before spending money on another pair, although it won’t compensate for a shoe that’s simply too big. Runner’s Loop A lacing technique that uses the top eyelets to create two small loops, which you cross and pull to lock your heel snugly in place.
- Shoes with a roomier forefoot and a snugger heel — some shoes are designed to provide extra space around the toes without being equally roomy at the back. You may see these described as having a ‘combination last’, although the term doesn’t guarantee a particular fit. Check the manufacturer’s fitting information and, whenever possible, try the shoes on.
- Heel grips or pads — these can help if your shoes fit well everywhere else but have a little too much room around the heel. They’re relatively inexpensive and easy to try, but they won’t fix shoes that are significantly too big or the wrong shape for your feet. Make sure they don’t create uncomfortable pressure or rubbing.
What I’d Actually Look For
If your shoes fit comfortably everywhere else but your heels still slip slightly, heel grips might be worth trying.
Dr.Foot makes self-adhesive heel grips that attach inside the back of your shoes. They may help take up a little spare room, although how well they work depends on the shoe and the shape of your heel.
I’d try a small adjustment like this before replacing an otherwise comfortable pair of shoes. But if the shoes are much too loose, I’d look for a better-fitting style instead.
Check Dr.Foot heel grips on Amazon
How to Tell If This Is Your Problem
If your toes have plenty of room but your heels keep lifting as you walk, the shoe may be too roomy around the back of your foot.
That doesn’t necessarily mean you need a narrower shoe all over. You might simply need a style that offers generous forefoot space with a closer fit around the heel.
Before buying anything else, check the shoe’s length as well. A shoe that’s too long can also allow your heel to slip, even when the width feels comfortable.
If you’re unsure whether your shoes are wide enough across the front, my guide to measuring foot width at home can help you get started.
But remember, the calculator compares forefoot measurements with Waldläufer’s width references. It doesn’t measure heel width or tell you whether a particular shoe will grip your heel properly. That’s something you’ll need to check when trying the shoes on.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I have wide feet and a narrow heel at the same time?
Yes, it’s a genuine and fairly common foot shape. It’s just less talked about than uniformly wide or uniformly narrow feet, so it’s often overlooked by both shoe brands and shoppers.
Why does my heel slip even in wide fit shoes?
Your heel might slip because the back of the shoe is too roomy, even though the forefoot fits comfortably.
But heel slipping can also happen if the shoe is too long, the shape doesn’t suit your foot, or the fastening isn’t holding your heel securely.
Not all wide fit shoes have wide heels, so it’s worth trying different styles rather than assuming you need a narrower fitting altogether.
Will going up a size fix heel slip?
Usually not, and it can make it worse — a bigger shoe often means even more room around the heel. A better fit or a lacing adjustment is generally more effective than sizing up.
The Bottom Line
Having wide feet doesn’t necessarily mean you need shoes that are wide everywhere.
If you’ve finally found shoes with enough room for your toes but your heels keep slipping, the problem could be the shape of the shoe rather than its overall width.
Try adjusting the laces first. Heel grips might help with a small amount of looseness, but they won’t rescue a badly fitting shoe.
And don’t assume going up or down a size will solve everything. Sometimes you simply need a different style that gives you room where you need it and a snugger fit where you don’t.
Medical disclaimer: This article shares general footwear advice and my personal experience of wearing wide-fitting shoes. It isn’t a substitute for professional medical advice. If you’re experiencing persistent heel pain, repeated blistering or difficulty walking, speak to a qualified healthcare professional, such as your GP or a podiatrist.
About Sue Holland
Sue writes WiderFittingShoes.com from first-hand experience of finding footwear for wide and difficult-to-fit feet. After two hip replacements, two ankle replacements and years of dealing with arthritis, swelling and feet that don’t always behave the same from one day to the next, she shares the practical things she’s learned about shoe fit, width and comfort.