Here’s something that took me a surprisingly long time to realise: buying wide fit shoes doesn’t automatically mean everything inside them is wide too. The insole — the bit your foot actually sits on — is usually still cut to a standard shape, even inside a wide shoe.
I came across this properly while looking into spare insoles for my own “one bigger foot” trick (I’ve written about that here), and it made me realise it’s worth its own explanation.
I’ll be honest, I’ve been buying standard insoles myself for years — the type that need cutting to size — when wide fit ones were available all along. I’d been using one of my removable insoles as a template each time, but the cut-down replacements never quite came out wide enough at the front. Turns out I was solving the wrong problem.
Affiliate disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you buy something through one of these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Why a Standard Insole Doesn’t Quite Work in a Wide Shoe
Some standard insoles fit perfectly well inside wide fit shoes, but others can be too narrow, particularly around the forefoot. If the replacement insole leaves a noticeable gap along the sides of the shoe, it may not provide the coverage or support you’re expecting.
That’s why I now check the actual width of an insole rather than assuming that buying the correct length means it’ll fit properly.
If an insole is too narrow for the shoe, you might notice gaps around its edges or find that it doesn’t sit quite as comfortably as you’d hoped. But if your foot is sliding around inside the shoe, don’t automatically blame the insole. The shoe itself could be too wide, too deep or simply the wrong shape for your foot.
Do You Actually Need One?
Not everyone in a wide fit shoe needs a wide fit insole specifically — if your shoes already feel genuinely supportive and stable, there’s no need to change anything. But it’s worth considering a wide fit insole if:
- You’ve bought wide fit shoes but still feel like your foot moves around inside them
- Your current insole feels like it’s bunching, curling at the edges, or not sitting flat
- You need arch support but a standard insole hasn’t felt right in your wide shoes
What I’d Actually Look For
Superfeet is one of the brands worth looking at if you need replacement insoles for wider shoes. But I wouldn’t buy an insole based on the word ‘wide’ alone.
I’d check its length, width and shape against the original insole from my shoe, particularly around the forefoot. I’d also make sure there’s enough room inside the shoe for any additional arch support or cushioning.
A wider insole isn’t automatically a better insole. It still needs to suit your feet and fit properly inside your shoes.
Check Superfeet Wide Fit insoles on Amazon
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a wide fit insole the same as a regular insole in a bigger size?
Not necessarily. Some wide fit insoles are designed with a broader shape, while others may simply offer more room in particular areas.
Buying a longer standard insole and trimming it down doesn’t guarantee it’ll be wide enough, especially around the forefoot. That’s something I discovered with my own replacement insoles.
I’d always compare the shape and width with the original insole before buying.
Do all wide fit shoes need a wide fit insole?
Not necessarily. If your current shoes and insoles already feel supportive and stable, there’s no need to change them. It’s worth considering if you notice your foot moving around or the insole not sitting flat.
The Bottom Line
Buying wide fit shoes doesn’t necessarily mean you need wide fit insoles as well.
If the original insoles fit comfortably and your feet feel supported, there’s no reason to replace them just because your shoes are wide.
But if you’re buying replacements, check more than the shoe size. The width and shape matter too, particularly around the forefoot.
I learned that the hard way after years of trimming ordinary insoles and wondering why they never quite fitted properly!
Medical disclaimer: This article shares my personal experience and general information about shoe and insole fitting. It isn’t a substitute for professional medical advice. If you’re experiencing persistent foot pain or difficulty walking, speak to a qualified healthcare professional, such as a podiatrist or your GP.
About Sue Holland
Sue writes WiderFittingShoes.com from first-hand experience of finding footwear for wide and difficult-to-fit feet. After two hip replacements, two ankle replacements and years of dealing with arthritis, swelling and feet that don’t always behave the same from one day to the next, she shares the practical things she’s learned about shoe fit, width and comfort.